http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/succesful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f18/-t1.htm Cases which have been successful in the SCCRC.This shows what evidence the courts and the SCCRC think is acceptable as a miscarriage of justice. Thu, 04 Sep 2008 15:50:29 GMT 10 http://i33.servimg.com/u/f33/12/93/77/53/logo10.jpg http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/succesful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f18/-t1.htm http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/succesful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f18/brian-kelly-t152.htm Admin Date Referred to Court:
14 December 2000
Offence:
Rape
Date of Conviction:
30 November 1989
Appeal Outcome:
Successful
Date of Appeal Outcome:
6 August 2004
Judgment:
http://www.scotcourts.gov.uk/opinions/XC458.html


More to be added]]> Succesful Cases Referred by the Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission Thu, 04 Sep 2008 15:41:35 GMT http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/succesful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f18/brian-kelly-t152.htm#195 http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/succesful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f18/brian-kelly-t152.htm http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/succesful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f18/jerzy-boncza-tomaszewski-also-known-as-george-fraser-t115.htm Admin http://www.scotcourts.gov.uk/opinions/C158_00.html APPEAL COURT, HIGH COURT OF JUSTICIARY Lord Justice General Lord Philip Lord Carloway C158/00 OPINION OF THE COURT delivered by THE LORD JUSTICE GENERAL in APPEAL AGAINST CONVICTION AND SENTENCE in causa JERZY BONCZA-TOMASZEWSKI (also known as GEORGE FRASER) Appellant; against HER MAJESTY'S ADVOCATE Respondent: _______ Appellant: ... Succesful Cases Referred by the Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission Thu, 04 Sep 2008 13:52:06 GMT http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/succesful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f18/jerzy-boncza-tomaszewski-also-known-as-george-fraser-t115.htm#142 http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/succesful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f18/jerzy-boncza-tomaszewski-also-known-as-george-fraser-t115.htm http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/succesful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f18/george-fraser-aka-jerzy-boncza-tomaszewski-t156.htm Admin Date Referred to Court:
22 September 1999
Offence:
assault; cruel and unnatural treatment
Date of Conviction:
25 May 1948
Appeal Outcome:
Successful
Date of Appeal Outcome:
2 June 2000
Judgment:
http://www.scotcourts.gov.uk/opinions/C158_00.html]]> Succesful Cases Referred by the Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission Thu, 04 Sep 2008 15:50:29 GMT http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/succesful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f18/george-fraser-aka-jerzy-boncza-tomaszewski-t156.htm#200 http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/succesful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f18/george-fraser-aka-jerzy-boncza-tomaszewski-t156.htm http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/succesful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f18/stuart-gair-t155.htm Admin Date Referred to Court:
11 November 1999
Offence:
Murder
Date of Conviction:
30 August 1999
Appeal Outcome:
Successful
Date of Appeal Outcome:
11 July 2006
Judgment:
no written judgement available]]> Succesful Cases Referred by the Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission Thu, 04 Sep 2008 15:45:22 GMT http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/succesful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f18/stuart-gair-t155.htm#198 http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/succesful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f18/stuart-gair-t155.htm http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/succesful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f18/iain-gibson-t151.htm Admin Date Referred to Court:
2 February 2001
Offence:
Assault and Breach of the Peace
Date of Conviction:
31 October 1995
Appeal Outcome:
Successful
Date of Appeal Outcome:
12 June 2001
Judgment:
no written judgement available[b]]]> Succesful Cases Referred by the Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission Thu, 04 Sep 2008 15:39:19 GMT http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/succesful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f18/iain-gibson-t151.htm#194 http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/succesful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f18/iain-gibson-t151.htm http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/succesful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f18/stuart-fulton-t150.htm Admin Date Referred to Court:
25 May 2001
Offence:
Firearms charges
Date of Conviction:
12 March 1998
Appeal Outcome:
Successful
Date of Appeal Outcome:
26 January 2005
Judgment:
http://www.scotcourts.gov.uk/opinions/HCJAC4.html]]> Succesful Cases Referred by the Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission Thu, 04 Sep 2008 15:38:32 GMT http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/succesful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f18/stuart-fulton-t150.htm#193 http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/succesful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f18/stuart-fulton-t150.htm http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/succesful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f18/raymond-gilmour-t149.htm Admin Date Referred to Court:
13 July 2001
Offence:
Murder
Date of Conviction:
7 June 1982
Appeal Outcome:
Successful
Date of Appeal Outcome:
30 August 2007
Judgment:
http://www.scotcourts.gov.uk/opinions/2007hcjac48.html]]> Succesful Cases Referred by the Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission Thu, 04 Sep 2008 15:33:36 GMT http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/succesful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f18/raymond-gilmour-t149.htm#189 http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/succesful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f18/raymond-gilmour-t149.htm http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/succesful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f18/steven-johnston-and-billy-allison-t147.htm Admin Steven Johnston Date Referred to Court: 19 June 2001 Offence: Murder Date of Conviction: 19 March 1996 Appeal Outcome: Successful Date of Appeal Outcome: 17 March 2006 Judgment: http://www.scotcourts.gov.uk/opinions/2006HCJAC30.html Billy Allison Date Referred to Court: 19 June 2001 Offence: Murder Date of Conviction: 19 March 1996 Appeal Outcome: Successful Date of Appeal Outcome: 17 March 2006 Judgment: http://www.scotcourts.gov.uk/opinions/2006HCJAC30.html Succesful Cases Referred by the Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission Thu, 04 Sep 2008 15:27:11 GMT http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/succesful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f18/steven-johnston-and-billy-allison-t147.htm#184 http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/succesful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f18/steven-johnston-and-billy-allison-t147.htm http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/succesful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f18/thomas-campbell-glasgow-two-case-t146.htm Admin Date Referred to Court:
28 November 2001
Offence:
Murder
Date of Conviction:
10 October 1984
Appeal Outcome:
Successful
Date of Appeal Outcome:
17 March 2004
Judgment:
http://www.scotcourts.gov.uk/opinions/XC956.html]]> Succesful Cases Referred by the Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission Thu, 04 Sep 2008 15:24:00 GMT http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/succesful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f18/thomas-campbell-glasgow-two-case-t146.htm#182 http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/succesful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f18/thomas-campbell-glasgow-two-case-t146.htm http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/succesful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f18/joseph-steele-glasgow-two-case-t145.htm Admin Date Referred to Court:
28 November 2001
Offence:
Murder
Date of Conviction:
10 October 1984
Appeal Outcome:
Successful
Date of Appeal Outcome:
17 March 2004
Judgment:
http://www.scotcourts.gov.uk/opinions/XC956.html]]> Succesful Cases Referred by the Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission Thu, 04 Sep 2008 15:20:32 GMT http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/succesful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f18/joseph-steele-glasgow-two-case-t145.htm#180 http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/succesful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f18/joseph-steele-glasgow-two-case-t145.htm http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/succesful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f18/stuart-kidd-t143.htm Admin Date Referred to Court:
14 October 2002
Offence:
Murder
Date of Conviction:
3 July 1996
Appeal Outcome:
Successful
Date of Appeal Outcome:
10 December 2004
Judgment:
http://www.scotcourts.gov.uk/opinions/2005HCJAC13.html]]> Succesful Cases Referred by the Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission Thu, 04 Sep 2008 15:17:09 GMT http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/succesful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f18/stuart-kidd-t143.htm#177 http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/succesful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f18/stuart-kidd-t143.htm http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/succesful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f18/george-mcphee-t141.htm Admin Date Referred to Court:
24 January 2003
Offence:
Murder
Date of Conviction:
4 December 1985
Appeal Outcome:
Successful
Date of Appeal Outcome:
6 December 2005

Judgment:
http://www.scotcourts.gov.uk/opinions/2005HCJAC137.html]]> Succesful Cases Referred by the Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission Thu, 04 Sep 2008 15:09:04 GMT http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/succesful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f18/george-mcphee-t141.htm#173 http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/succesful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f18/george-mcphee-t141.htm http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/succesful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f18/john-mcginty-t137.htm Admin Date Referred to Court:
24 January 2003
Offence:
Drugs offences
Date of Conviction:
12 June 1997
Appeal Outcome:
Successful
Date of Appeal Outcome:
18 January 2006
Judgment:
http://www.scotcourts.gov.uk/opinions/2006hcjac08.html]]> Succesful Cases Referred by the Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission Thu, 04 Sep 2008 15:00:08 GMT http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/succesful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f18/john-mcginty-t137.htm#169 http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/succesful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f18/john-mcginty-t137.htm http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/succesful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f18/jamie-orr-you-couldn-t-swing-a-cat-t133.htm Admin Jamie Orr Date Referred to Court: 29 August 2003 Offence: Animal cruelty Date of Conviction: 26 January 2000 Appeal Outcome: Successful Date of Appeal Outcome: 29 June 2005 Judgment: No written judgement available SCCRC referred this following case for which the High Court have not produced an opinion, (Wonder Why) Cat torture conviction overturned A man found guilty of torturing a cat has won a six-year legal battle to clear his name. Jamie Orr, from ... Succesful Cases Referred by the Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission Thu, 04 Sep 2008 14:52:11 GMT http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/succesful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f18/jamie-orr-you-couldn-t-swing-a-cat-t133.htm#165 http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/succesful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f18/jamie-orr-you-couldn-t-swing-a-cat-t133.htm http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/succesful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f18/colette-gilmour-t130.htm Admin Colette Gilmour Date Referred to Court: 5 November 2004 Offence: Theft Date of Conviction: 28 March 2000 Appeal Outcome: Successful Date of Appeal Outcome: 8/2/2005 Judgment: No written judgement available SCOTTISH CRIMINAL CASES REVIEW COMMISSION NEWS RELEASE The Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission has referred to the High Court the case of Colette Gilmour in respect of her Conviction. Colette Gilmour was convicted at Falkirk District Court on 28 March ... Succesful Cases Referred by the Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission Thu, 04 Sep 2008 14:41:46 GMT http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/succesful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f18/colette-gilmour-t130.htm#161 http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/succesful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f18/colette-gilmour-t130.htm http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/succesful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f18/william-freeburn-t126.htm Admin William Freeburn Date Referred to Court: 13 September 2005 Offence: Attempted theft Date of Conviction: 10 September 2002 Appeal Outcome: Successful Date of Appeal Outcome: 17 November 2005 Judgment: No written judgement available SCOTTISH CRIMINAL CASES REVIEW COMMISSION NEWS RELEASE The Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission has this month referred the following cases to the High Court;- 1. The case of William Freeburn in respect of conviction. William ... Succesful Cases Referred by the Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission Thu, 04 Sep 2008 14:30:26 GMT http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/succesful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f18/william-freeburn-t126.htm#156 http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/succesful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f18/william-freeburn-t126.htm