http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/unsuccessful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f19/-t1.htm Cases which have been unsuccessful with the SCCRC.This shows what is deemed not to be acceptable as evidence. Thu, 04 Sep 2008 15:44:13 GMT 10 http://i33.servimg.com/u/f33/12/93/77/53/logo10.jpg http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/unsuccessful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f19/-t1.htm http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/unsuccessful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f19/hugh-mccormack-t154.htm Admin Date Referred to Court:
14 July 2000
Offence:
Murder
Date of Conviction:
16 January 1992
Appeal Outcome:
unsucessful
Date of Appeal Outcome:
31 March 2005
Judgment:
http://www.scotcourts.gov.uk/opinions/2005HCAC38.html]]> Unsuccessful Cases Referred by the Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission Thu, 04 Sep 2008 15:44:13 GMT http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/unsuccessful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f19/hugh-mccormack-t154.htm#197 http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/unsuccessful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f19/hugh-mccormack-t154.htm http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/unsuccessful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f19/james-crombie-t153.htm Admin Date Referred to Court:
15 August 2000
Offence:
Fraud
Date of Conviction:
31 October 1991
Appeal Outcome:
unsuccessful
Date of Appeal Outcome:
8 March 2001
Judgment:
http://www.scotcourts.gov.uk/opinions/2472_00.html]]> Unsuccessful Cases Referred by the Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission Thu, 04 Sep 2008 15:42:55 GMT http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/unsuccessful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f19/james-crombie-t153.htm#196 http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/unsuccessful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f19/james-crombie-t153.htm http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/unsuccessful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f19/thomas-gray-t144.htm Admin Date Referred to Court:
30 November 2001
Offence:
Attempted murder
Date of Conviction:
10 October 1984
Appeal Outcome:
unsuccessful
Date of Appeal Outcome:
17 March 2004
Judgment:
http://www.scotcourts.gov.uk/opinions/XC956.html]]> Unsuccessful Cases Referred by the Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission Thu, 04 Sep 2008 15:19:34 GMT http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/unsuccessful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f19/thomas-gray-t144.htm#179 http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/unsuccessful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f19/thomas-gray-t144.htm http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/unsuccessful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f19/ronald-neeson-t142.htm Admin Date Referred to Court:
29 November 2002
Offence:
Murder
Date of Conviction:
17 March 1983
Appeal Outcome:
Unsuccessful
Date of Appeal Outcome:
13 September 2006

Judgment:
http://www.scotcourts.gov.uk/opinions/HCJAC68.html

Judgement is too long to copy.]]> Unsuccessful Cases Referred by the Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission Thu, 04 Sep 2008 15:15:14 GMT http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/unsuccessful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f19/ronald-neeson-t142.htm#176 http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/unsuccessful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f19/ronald-neeson-t142.htm http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/unsuccessful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f19/william-gray-t140.htm Admin Date Referred to Court:
31 January 2003
Offence:
Murder
Date of Conviction:
2 October 1992
Appeal Outcome:
unsuccessful
Date of Appeal Outcome:
23 December 2004

Judgment: Please read here. too long to copy
www.scotcourts.gov.uk/opinions/LJC3011.html]]> Unsuccessful Cases Referred by the Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission Thu, 04 Sep 2008 15:07:53 GMT http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/unsuccessful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f19/william-gray-t140.htm#172 http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/unsuccessful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f19/william-gray-t140.htm http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/unsuccessful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f19/james-orourke-t139.htm Admin Date Referred to Court:
31 January 2003
Offence:
Murder
Date of Conviction:
3 October 1982
Appeal Outcome:
unsuccessful
Date of Appeal Outcome:
23 December 2004

Judgment:
www.scotcourts.gov.uk/opinions/LJC3011.html

Judgement too long to copy read above.]]> Unsuccessful Cases Referred by the Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission Thu, 04 Sep 2008 15:06:48 GMT http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/unsuccessful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f19/james-orourke-t139.htm#171 http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/unsuccessful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f19/james-orourke-t139.htm http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/unsuccessful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f19/jason-harper-t138.htm Admin Date Referred to Court:
24 January 2003
Offence:
Murder
Date of Conviction:
27 January 1993
Appeal Outcome:
unsuccessful
Date of Appeal Outcome:
15 March 2005
Judgment:
http://www.scotcourts.gov.uk/opinions/2005HCJAC23.html


Decision too long to post see the judgement above.]]> Unsuccessful Cases Referred by the Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission Thu, 04 Sep 2008 15:04:30 GMT http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/unsuccessful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f19/jason-harper-t138.htm#170 http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/unsuccessful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f19/jason-harper-t138.htm http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/unsuccessful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f19/michael-bishop-t135.htm Admin Michael Bishop Date Referred to Court: 13 March 2003 Offence: Indecent Assault; contravention of section 10 of the Video Recordings Act 1984 Date of Conviction: 11 January 2000 Appeal Outcome: unsuccessful Date of Appeal Outcome: 11 March 2005 Judgment: http://www.scotcourts.gov.uk/opinions/2005HCJAC40.html APPEAL COURT, HIGH COURT OF JUSTICIARY Lord Justice General Lord Macfadyen Lord Carloway [2005HCJAC40] Appeal No: XJ531/03 OPINION ... Unsuccessful Cases Referred by the Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission Thu, 04 Sep 2008 14:55:40 GMT http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/unsuccessful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f19/michael-bishop-t135.htm#167 http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/unsuccessful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f19/michael-bishop-t135.htm http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/unsuccessful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f19/thomas-thomson-t134.htm Admin Thomas Thomson Date Referred to Court: 12 January 2004 Offence: Rape Date of Conviction: 10 August 1999 Appeal Outcome: unsuccessful Date of Appeal Outcome: 26 January 2005 Judgment: http://www.scotcourts.gov.uk/opinions/HCJAC7.html APPEAL COURT, HIGH COURT OF JUSTICIARY Lord Justice Clerk Lord MacLean Lord Macfadyen [2005HCJAC7] Appeal No: XC20/04 OPINION OF THE COURT delivered by LORD MACFADYEN in the reference by THE ... Unsuccessful Cases Referred by the Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission Thu, 04 Sep 2008 14:53:35 GMT http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/unsuccessful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f19/thomas-thomson-t134.htm#166 http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/unsuccessful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f19/thomas-thomson-t134.htm http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/unsuccessful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f19/leo-tonks-appeal-abandoned-t128.htm Admin Leo Tonks
Date Referred to Court:
1 April 2005
Offence:
Theft by housebreaking and assult to injury
Date of Conviction:
7 September 2000
Appeal Outcome:
Appeal abandoned
Date of Appeal Outcome:
17 November 2005

Further info to be added]]> Unsuccessful Cases Referred by the Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission Thu, 04 Sep 2008 14:37:40 GMT http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/unsuccessful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f19/leo-tonks-appeal-abandoned-t128.htm#159 http://scotchedjustice.forumotion.com/unsuccessful-cases-referred-by-the-scottish-criminal-cases-review-commission-f19/leo-tonks-appeal-abandoned-t128.htm